Niagara Falls, which straddles the international border between Canada and the United States, was one of the first mass-market tourism destinations and remains popular with over 20 million yearly visitors between the two sides.
Most who come to see the waterfalls don’t stay in Niagara Falls, New York. Instead, they go to Niagara Falls, Ontario, which for decades has lured tourists with more attractions, more hotels and more restaurants.
Yes, the dilapidation that comes after a city loses over half of its population since 1960 is everywhere. City Hall, desperate to stop the decline, thought a gimmick offering student loan repayment would entice millenials to Niagara Falls. Empty storefronts are everywhere. Downtown could be a case study in 1970s and 1980s city planning gone wrong. The architecture of newer buildings is inconsistent, if not hideous. Good restaurants are few and far between, unless TGI Fridays and Rainforest Cafe are your thing.
None of that is to say the Canadian side is better. Yes, it has more hotels, but Niagara Falls, Ontario, is grossly overdeveloped to the point where high-rise towers ruin what would be a pristine vista. Around the hotels sits a dumpy tourist trap.
Built by the French in the early 18th century on the site of two earlier forts and trading posts from the 17th century, Fort Niagara is strategically situated at the point where Lake Ontario and the Niagara River meet.
Two battles were fought here during the French and Indian War, as the North American theater of the wider Seven Years’ War between France and Great Britain from 1756–1763 is called, and the War of 1812. Largely forgotten today, the wars played important roles in shaping the history of the United States and Canada. In-between, during the American Revolution, the fort was also a key British outpost until the United States finally took control of it in 1796.
Treasures Await at This Old Cathedral in Canada Leaf Peeping Through History in Michigan’s Keweenaw Peninsula The Unexpected: An Old, Locked Up Church in the Middle of Nowhere History and Architecture, Not Wings Await in Buffalo
Alternate history enthusiasts will enjoy speculating on how France could have remained a power in North America and the 13 colonies wouldn’t have declared independence in 1776 had the battle at Fort Niagara in 1759 and the Seven Years’ War itself turned out differently.
Today, Old Fort Niagara consists of fortifications and buildings that range from the early French period through the 19th century improvements made by the United States after the War of 1812. Daily programming features interpreters portraying soldiers from the fort’s French, British and American periods through demonstrations of musket and artillery firings, military drills and even period fife and drum music.
Leaving the fort I drove New York State Route 18F, which runs along the Niagara River and turns into Main Street at Youngstown (population 1,910). The village’s downtown includes a couple of cafés and art galleries, quaint historic houses and a handsome postbellum Episcopal church built in the style of Carpenter Gothic. Just down the byway, about halfway between the fort and Niagara Falls, is Lewiston, a slightly bigger village (population 2,701) with noticeably more shops, cafés and restaurants.
Over 20 wineries, including Arrowhead Spring Vineyards and Freedom Run Winery, are operating, thanks to a unique microclimate created by Lake Ontario and the Niagara Escarpment. The same microclimate is also responsible for the better-known wine appellation on the Canadian side of the border.
Opinions run deep, as one might expect, about which side of the border has the best views of the American Falls, Bridal Veil Falls and Horseshoe Falls. However, as far as I’m concerned Niagara Falls U.S.A. is the winner, thanks to the Niagara Falls State Park.
The 221 acres of parkland, which owes its existence to acclaimed 19th century landscape architect Frederick Law Olmsted, takes you to within feet of the waterfalls. You could spend hours in the country’s oldest state park — it makes the perfect spot for a picnic.
If you go
I stayed downtown at the Sheraton Niagara Falls, which has super reasonable rates. However, the food was horrible and the hotel charged a ridiculous daily resort fee, despite not being a resort. Still, it’s within walking distance of the Niagara Falls State Park.
For wine tasting tours you might want to consider a five-hour excursion from Gray Line that costs $62.96 per person and runs through the end of October. Another option is the Niagara USA Wine Festival, which is held every July.